Skip to content

Realistic live bench via camofox + shortlist crash fix #9

Description

@espetro

integration/out/comparison.json scored 0% on both arms — not a verdict on HTLM, a broken instrument: ~30-40% of tasks structurally unwinnable against a flagged, automation-detected headless Chromium (Cloudflare/CAPTCHA/access-denied), plus a real crash (PlanShortlist.shortlist_indices unbounded, minimax emits huge index lists, JSON truncates, pydantic fails, 4/20 htlm tasks lost). Swap in the anti-detection camofox browser (Camoufox/Firefox fork, REST API on :9377, own snapshot/action format — needs a bridge, not a drop-in for browser-use's BrowserSession) so the live A/B (llm vs htlm grounder, from #7) measures grounding, not bot-detection.

Plan: .agents/plans/2026-07-16-live-proof-of-work.md (Track A)

Deliverables:

  • integration/camofox_adapter.pysnapshot_to_page (camofox accessibility refs → integer index, camofox roles → map_mind2web._map_role categories) + action_to_camofox (action → REST call).
  • integration/run_bench_camofox.py (or --browser {chromium,camofox} flag on run_bench.py) — same loop/planner/judge, camofox session; keep the llm/htlm A/B intact.
  • integration/planner.py:89 crash fix — bound shortlist_indices (max_length=64, matching the prompt's stated cap) and/or hard-truncate in Planner.shortlist. Land regardless of the rest of this track.
  • Bucket/skip judge-flagged impossible_task/captcha rows so the reported number reflects winnable tasks only.

Success = a non-degenerate live success number (not both-arms-0%) that separates the htlm and llm arms, written to integration/out/ with a short results note. Background/secondary to #8 — offline 91.2% stays the primary claim.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    infraClassification: infra

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions