Repository navigation
Description
Description
Every page that renders a List (and so every CheckboxList, which renders one) bundles List's row layout animation, though only a List given animatedLayout ever runs it. List.tsx imports useListLayoutUpdates from ./listLayoutUpdates statically (L43) and calls it on every render (L359); without the handle the hook returns early. ListItem.tsx also imports isReportedRow and keepPresentation from the same module (L61). listLayoutUpdates in turn imports motion/animatedLayout (playLayoutChange, holdLayoutExit, reportLayoutChange, landLayoutGlideSideways), so the whole glide machinery comes with any list: 11.4 kB of JavaScript gzipped on a page with one CheckboxList.
It came with List's animatedLayout (#8106, 0.7.12).
Expected: a page whose lists don't take animatedLayout doesn't load the layout-update modules. Actual: it loads all of them.
Reproduction
A Vite 8.3.8 production build with React 19.3.1 and @astryxdesign/core 0.7.15, of this entry alone:
import { createElement as h, useState } from 'react';
import { createRoot } from 'react-dom/client';
import { CheckboxList, CheckboxListItem } from '@astryxdesign/core/CheckboxList';
function App() {
const [value, setValue] = useState(['email']);
return h(CheckboxList, { label: 'Notify me by', value, onChange: setValue },
h(CheckboxListItem, { label: 'Email', value: 'email' }),
h(CheckboxListItem, { label: 'SMS', value: 'sms' }),
h(CheckboxListItem, { label: 'Push', value: 'push' }),
);
}
createRoot(document.getElementById('root')).render(h(App));Then the same build with one change: a resolver plugin swaps ./listLayoutUpdates.js, when List/List.js or List/ListItem.js imports it, for a stub with the same exports:
const noop = () => {};
export function useListLayoutUpdates() { return noop; }
export function isReportedRow() { return false; }
export function keepPresentation() {}In Chromium both builds render the three checkboxes, toggle them, and log no errors.
| Build | JS loaded up front, gzip level 9 |
|---|---|
React and react-dom alone (<p>Hello</p>) |
67.5 kB |
One CheckboxList |
151.1 kB |
The same, listLayoutUpdates stubbed |
139.7 kB |
The stub removes five modules from the build: List/listLayoutUpdates, motion/animatedLayout, motion/presentation, privateAttributes/leaving.stylex and privateAttributes/reducedMotion.stylex.
Still the same on main (96ea823): the imports at List.tsx L43 and ListItem.tsx L61 are unchanged.
Possible directions: an app that passes animatedLayout has already imported useAnimatedLayout, so the handle could carry the row reporter and List would call it only when the handle is set; or List could load listLayoutUpdates with a dynamic import() the first time it gets a handle. isReportedRow and keepPresentation only read the shared reported-rows map, so they could live in a small module of their own that ListItem imports. The same pattern as #11570 (Button's tooltip layer) and #11569 (Table's cell context menu).
Astryx Version
0.7.15 (also main 96ea823)
Environment
Any browser; a bundle-size issue. Measured with Vite 8.3.8 (Rolldown), React 19.3.1, Node, Linux; module list from the build's source maps; render checked in headless Chromium (Playwright 1.64).
Activity
cixzhang commentedon Nov 14, 2026
(Posted by Cindy's agent.)
Thanks for the clear report and the Vite repro. The fix is in #11635 (draft, in review).
useAnimatedLayout's handle now carries the four layout calls a List makes, and List reads them from the handle it is given. A List without a handle, and so everyCheckboxList, no longer loads the row layout animation. Measured on app pages:Lists given a handle animate their rows as before. We'll post again here when it ships.